Reformation Red Pill

Unpacking confessional Reformed theology through lively discussions and debates.

weekly

73 episodes

90 min avg

Christian Living Culture & News Interview Longform Conversation Panel Discussion

Visit Website Apple Podcasts Spotify RSS Feed

What is Reformation Red Pill?

Reformation Red Pill is a podcast hosted by Pastor Brooks Potteiger and Joshua Haymes that chronicles their journey into confessional Reformed theology after moving away from broader evangelicalism. They engage in discussions and debates on various theological topics, often reacting to and analyzing current events and figures within the Reformed world. The podcast aims to explore and promote a deeper understanding of Reformed doctrines.

Who is Reformation Red Pill For?

Reformation Red Pill is primarily for Christians who are:

Interested in exploring or deepening their understanding of Reformed theology.
Potentially disillusioned with aspects of mainstream evangelicalism.
Open to engaging with sometimes challenging or debated theological topics.
Interested in listening to discussions and debates from a confessional Reformed perspective.
Looking for a podcast that tackles specific theological issues with a strong point of view.

Recent Episodes

Redeemed Zoomer Claims Evangelicals Aren’t REAL Protestants: Is He Right? w/Paul Liberati

CLUB MEMBERSHIP: https://theforge.press/rrp-members Contact: reformationredpillpodcast@gmail.com On this episode of Reformation Red Pill Joshua Haymes, and Pastor Paul Liberati Interact with Redeemed Zoomer’s Recent Interview with Catholic apologist Trent Horn. RZ Claims that Evangelicals aren’t true protestants. Is he right? We make the case that evangelicals are in fact real Protestants. Our Wonderful Sponsors: Backwards Planning Financial https://www.northwesternmutual.com/financial/advisor/joe-garrisi/planning Joe Garrisi - 615-767-2555 Resurrection Design Co. Christian Graphic Designer specializing in Branding & Website Design. resurrectiondesign.co/reformation MT Athos Performance https://athosperform.com/ Discount Code: REFORMATION David Reece Reecefund https://reecefund.com/ https://x.com/RealDavidReece?ref_src=twsrc%5Egoogle%7Ctwcamp%5Eserp%7Ctwgr%5Eauthor Armored Republic https://www.ar500armor.com/?g_adgroupid=&g_acctid=756-317-3779&g_keywordid=&g_network=x&g_keyword=&g_adtype=none&g_adid=&g_campaignid=15492191451&g_campaign=%28PMax%29+-+BOF+-+Remarketing&gad_source=1&gad_campaignid=15495230155&gbraid=0AAAAADvfd9_K-7ywafIGaYbmLvDzndpYw&gclid=CjwKCAjw3MXBBhAzEiwA0vLXQeR1OqnG_Md-4Ua1R0ADXtYA2vZYq9ji7NDjE6k00eGwkKxim0qRCBoCD24QAvD_BwE

May 27, 20251h 31m

Can God TRULY Sanctify Black People? James White Debates “Christian” Hitler Apologist (Reaction)

CLUB MEMBERSHIP: https://theforge.press/rrp-members Patreon deplatformed us! Join our exclusive members' club by using the link above! Donate Here: https://theforge.press/donate Contact: reformationredpillpodcast@gmail.com On this episode of Reformation Red Pill Joshua Haymes, and pastor Brooks Potteiger react to and analyze the debate between Corey Mahler and Dr. James White on whether or not black people can be sanctified to the same degree as white people. Our Wonderful Sponsors: David Reece https://reecefund.com/ https://x.com/RealDavidReece Backwards Planning Financial https://www.northwesternmutual.com/financial/advisor/joe-garrisi/planning Joe Garrisi - 615-767-2555 Resurrection Design Co. Christian Graphic Designer specializing in Branding & Website Design. https://resurrectiondesign.co/reformation MT Athos Performance https://athosperform.com/ Discount Code: REFORMATION

May 21, 2025

LIVESTREAM - Understanding The New Christian RIght (& Why It Matters) w/Jon Harris

CLUB MEMBERSHIP: https://theforge.press/rrp-members Patreon deplatformed us! Join our exclusive members' club by using the link above! Donate Here: https://theforge.press/donate Contact: reformationredpillpodcast@gmail.com On this episode of Reformation Red Pill Joshua Haymes interviews Jon Harris and discusses the rising movement that has come to be called the New Christian Right. They then go on to discuss why it matters. Our Wonderful Sponsors: David Reece https://reecefund.com/ https://x.com/RealDavidReece Backwards Planning Financial https://www.northwesternmutual.com/financial/advisor/joe-garrisi/planning Joe Garrisi - 615-767-2555 Resurrection Design Co. Christian Graphic Designer specializing in Branding & Website Design. https://resurrectiondesign.co/reformation MT Athos Performance https://athosperform.com/ Discount Code: REFORMATION Resources: Understanding The NCR original Video: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=euIiWvs2CgI&t=1712s&ab_channel=ConversationsThatMatter Six Cautions for the New Christian Right https://truthscript.com/church/six-cautions-for-the-new-christian-right/

May 17, 20251h 42m

Polygamy & The Bible: Does Scripture TRULY Forbid POLYGAMY? w/Paul Liberati

CLUB MEMBERSHIP: https://theforge.press/rrp-members Patreon deplatformed us! Join our exclusive members' club by using the link above! Donate Here: https://theforge.press/donate Contact: reformationredpillpodcast@gmail.com On this episode of Reformation Red Pill Joshua Haymes, Pastor Paul Liberati make their case that the Bible forbids polygamy/polygyny. Our Wonderful Sponsors: David Reece https://reecefund.com/ https://x.com/RealDavidReece?ref_src=twsrc%5Egoogle%7Ctwcamp%5Eserp%7Ctwgr%5Eauthor Backwards Planning Financial https://www.northwesternmutual.com/financial/advisor/joe-garrisi/planning Joe Garrisi - 615-767-2555 Resurrection Design Co. Christian Graphic Designer specializing in Branding & Website Design. resurrectiondesign.co/reformation MT Athos Performance https://athosperform.com/ Discount Code: REFORMATION

May 12, 20251h 33m

4 Reasons Christians NEED To Be Reading Fiction w/ N.D. Haupt

CLUB MEMBERSHIP: https://theforge.press/rrp-members Patreon deplatformed us! Join our exclusive members' club by using the link above! Donate Here: https://theforge.press/donate Contact: reformationredpillpodcast@gmail.com BUY N.D. Haupt's Book The Cottage https://www.amazon.com/Cottage-N-D-Haupt/dp/1956611088 On this episode of RRP we make our case for why Christians NEED to be reading fiction. 1. God is a storyteller. 2. We are story people. 3. To cultivate evangelical dexterity. 4. To cultivate an artistic palette because good art REFORMS culture! Our Wonderful Sponsors: David Reece https://reecefund.com/https://x.com/RealDavidReece?ref_src=twsrc%5Egoogle%7Ctwcamp%5Eserp%7Ctwgr%5Eauthor Backwards Planning Financial https://www.northwesternmutual.com/financial/advisor/joe-garrisi/planning Joe Garrisi - 615-767-2555 Resurrection Design Co. Christian Graphic Designer specializing in Branding & Website Design. resurrectiondesign.co/reformation MT Athos Performance https://athosperform.com/ Discount Code: REFORMATION Brooks' Recommendations: - That Hideous Strength (Lewis) - The Count of Monte Cristo (Dumas) - The Man Who Was Thursday (Chesterton) - The Pilgrim’s Progress (Bunyan) - The Portrait of Dorian Grey (Wilde) - Bonus short story: A Crazy Tale (Chesterton) Naomi's Recommendations: - To Kill a Mockingbird by Harper Lee (age 14 and up) - Ralph Moody series (not technically fiction since it’s Moody’s life story, but highly readable and so good) - Pride and Prejudice by Jane Austen - 100 Cupboards series by N.D. Wilson - Peace Like a River by Leif Enger (age 14 and up) Joshua's Recommendations: - East of Eden - John Steinbeck - Anna Karenina - Tolstoy - Dracula - Bram Stoker - Watership Down - Richard Adams - Lonesome Dove - Larry Mcmurrty (Joshua's Bonus' because it's my podcast) - Red Rising - Pierce Brown - (my all-time favorite modern sci-fi) - Hyperion - Dan Simmons - Dune - Frank Herbert - All Lewis' Fiction. Every. Single Book. - Of course LOTR Honestly I could keep going, but this is a good start.

May 2, 20251h 17m